but I guess that is useless to KOUKI huh… well I dont care anymore, here wishing that you would experience what you’ve said to yourself a hundred times so that one day you can understand it.

and by the way criticisms given to a certain individual has its own limits. as I have said
like a child given candy he/she can only criticize the taste or appearance never can that child say “you SHOULD always” -_- understand your own message too, it that was not your point in you message then check the manner you said it

you SHOULD check it yourself….
you MUST check it yourslef…
how is it different? kindly educate me sir

I am not quite sure which broken links you mean? I always check the ToC and the previous chapter right after releasing a chapter to see that the links are proper and working.

Of course if you mean links for chapters that haven’t been released yet, then they would be “broken”, yes.

You know, repeating yourself doesn’t increase the validity of your statement.
Also, I really don’t think you actually know what a troll is…

Just let me say this:
I’m kind of amazed at how splendidly you managed to miss every single point he made. As well as every single point I made.
Moreover, your idea on how criticism works is fundamentally faulty. In regards to “fan translations” and anything else.

You might also want to take note of the fact that not once did I use the word “must”, but “should”. This implies that I’m fully aware that I have no real way of actually “forcing” him. Thus, attempting to do so would be pointless, wouldn’t it?

But assuming you want to do a “good job”, there will always be certain guidelines you have to follow. That’s simply how it is and there is no way around it.
Unless you have super powers that can bend reality maybe.

As for the matter of who actually established these guidelines, this “common sense”: Well, you might want to try actually talking to translators from established groups. Yes, other “fan translators”. It might just open your eyes, if only a little.

On the internet, there is such a thing as trolling. Moreoever, there is such a thing as trolling with polite and logical-sounding arguments, and yet it’s still trolling. Is it necessary to keep insisting “you’re doing it wrong, do it this way” after replies are posted to the point of it being tiring?

By the way, what you’re doing can, depending on situation, also be referred to as defamation. Which is also a felony. You might want to be aware of that. At the same time, I have little interest in the opinions of people who are unable to judge things objectively. So no real damage done.

Nor am I sure what I could have said to cause this rather exaggerated reaction from you. I neither remember using foul language nor calling you names. I didn’t slander you nor did I try to organize a mob to send after you. I wasn’t even being condescending. So what exactly is your deal?

And for the record, you generally have three choices when it comes to dealing with any form of criticism:
A. You accept the feedback and try to improve accordingly.
B. You ignore the feedback (vehemently defend yourself) but, as a consequence, will then also have to deal with more negative feedback in the future.
C. You stop doing what you’re doing altogether. That way, there will be nothing to even comment on. Though I’d like to think that’s the option you’d prefer the least.

oops sorry for venting 😀